We pointed last week to an analysis by Lynn Syzmoniak that showed that foreclosures across a number of different servicers were way down in January 2011 versus the same period in January 2010. This was admittedly a tally in only two Florida counties, but she indicated that a quick look at other counties in Florida showed a similar pattern.
So the question then becomes: is this a Florida only development, due perhaps in part the fact that all the big foreclosure mills in the state are under investigation by the state AG and are imploding (as in losing clients and shedding staff)? Or is this a broader trend due to the robo signing scandal leading judges being more receptive to arguments about chain of title and validity of transfers? Before, the assumption was “bank right, borrower trying to abuse the law to stay in house”. Now more judges, seeing that banks have run roughshod over legal requirements, are prepared to give borrower arguments a hearing. That forces banks to up their game, which in turn may be the real driver for this apparent slowdown in foreclosure actions. If that was the main driver in Florida, we’d expect to see similar patterns in other states.
We are seeing analogous developments, but the drivers appear to be state specific, as judges give adverse rulings on common practices in foreclosure land. Reader wc4d pointed to a report in the Portland Oregonian, that lenders are withdrawing cases because five court decisions have found that lenders that used MERS violated state recording laws.
This is a vivid illustration of a point made in an article on MERS yesterday by Gretchen Morgenson:
MERS was flawed at conception, those critics say. The bankers who midwifed its birth hired Covington & Burling, a prominent Washington law firm, to research their proposal. Covington produced a memo that offered assurances that MERS could operate legally nationwide. No one, however, conducted a state-by-state study of real estate laws.
“They didn’t do the deep homework,” said an official involved in those discussions who spoke on condition of anonymity because he has clients involved with MERS. “So as far as anyone can tell their real theory was: ‘If we can get everyone on board, no judge will want to upend something that is reasonable and sensible and would screw up 70 percent of loans.’ ”
As we’ve also noted, recording clerks in single counties in Massachusetts and North Carolina are looking into how to recover recording fees from MERS, but the cost of litigation means they’d need other counties in the same states to join or the state attorney general to take up the matter. By contrast, the Oregon decisions don’t hit small fry MERS; they are a big problem for the banks themselves. As the Oregonian reports:
Sales of hundreds of foreclosed homes in Oregon have been halted or withdrawn in recent weeks after federal judges repeatedly questioned their legality, according to a number of real estate attorneys in the state.
Lenders have withdrawn more than 300 foreclosure sales since February in Deschutes County alone, one of the Oregon area’s hardest hit by the housing collapse. About 130 of those notices were filed in the past week, attorneys say.
Dozens of foreclosure listings by ReconTrust Co., the foreclosure arm of Bank of America Corp., have disappeared from its website, attorneys say…
Since October, federal judges in five separate Oregon cases have halted foreclosures involving MERS, saying its participation caused lenders to violate the state’s recording law. Three of those decisions came last month, the key one in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Eugene.
Attorneys say it’s not clear whether lenders in Oregon will simply start over or head to court to foreclose, steps that could prolong the crisis for months and drive up costs, attorneys say. Some suggest lenders might not have access to the documents they need to comply with state law.
“A lot of us are questioning whether there is a solution,” said David Ambrose, a Portland attorney who represents lenders in mortgage transactions. “It’s pretty amazing. There are a lot of unanswered questions.” ….
In Oregon, lenders can foreclose without going to court. But state law also requires that the loan’s ownership history, or assignments, be recorded with local county governments before proceeding with a nonjudicial foreclosure.
In the Eugene court case, Donald E. McCoy III filed for bankruptcy protection in part to block U.S. Bank from foreclosing on his Central Point home. He then sued the bank and MERS, along with his original lender BNC Mortgage Inc., claiming they had not properly recorded BNC’s subsequent sale of the loan to investors.
Chief Bankruptcy Judge Frank R. Alley III found McCoy’s allegation persuasive and refused to grant the bank’s request for a dismissal.
“Oregon law permits foreclosure without the benefit of judicial proceeding only when the interest of the beneficiary (lender) is clearly documented in a public record,” Alley wrote. “When the public record is lacking, the foreclosing beneficiary must prove its interest in a judicial proceeding.”
This looks like an epic fail for the banks, at least in Oregon. To save maybe $50 on recording fees, they are now going to have to go to court to foreclose. And worse for them will be cases where the records don’t pass muster. Recall that servicers advance principal and interest to investors when borrowers become delinquent. They then reimburse themselves out of the foreclosure proceeds. No foreclosure and they are out a lot of dough.
As Morgenson’s source indicated, the banks brazenly assumed that the courts would simply roll over rather than block the extra-legal imposition of a new system. But there is enough of a semblance of rule of law in the US to undermine all the cost savings and corners-cutting they engaged in. Recall this recent New York decision:
This court does not accept the argument that because MERS may be involved with 50 percent of all residential mortgages in the country, that is reason enough for this court to turn a blind eye to the fact that this process does not comply with the law.
The courts are delivering the banks an unrelenting series of deserved unkind cuts. This is getting to be interesting, and for a change, in a good way.
We pointed last week to an analysis by Lynn Syzmoniak that showed that foreclosures across a number of different servicers were way down in January 2011 versus the same period in January 2010. This was admittedly a tally in only two Florida counties, but she indicated that a quick look at other counties in Florida showed a similar pattern.
So the question then becomes: is this a Florida only development, due perhaps in part the fact that all the big foreclosure mills in the state are under investigation by the state AG and are imploding (as in losing clients and shedding staff)? Or is this a broader trend due to the robo signing scandal leading judges being more receptive to arguments about chain of title and validity of transfers? Before, the assumption was “bank right, borrower trying to abuse the law to stay in house”. Now more judges, seeing that banks have run roughshod over legal requirements, are prepared to give borrower arguments a hearing. That forces banks to up their game, which in turn may be the real driver for this apparent slowdown in foreclosure actions. If that was the main driver in Florida, we’d expect to see similar patterns in other states.
We are seeing analogous developments, but the drivers appear to be state specific, as judges give adverse rulings on common practices in foreclosure land. Reader wc4d pointed to a report in the Portland Oregonian, that lenders are withdrawing cases because five court decisions have found that lenders that used MERS violated state recording laws.
This is a vivid illustration of a point made in an article on MERS yesterday by Gretchen Morgenson:
MERS was flawed at conception, those critics say. The bankers who midwifed its birth hired Covington & Burling, a prominent Washington law firm, to research their proposal. Covington produced a memo that offered assurances that MERS could operate legally nationwide. No one, however, conducted a state-by-state study of real estate laws.
“They didn’t do the deep homework,” said an official involved in those discussions who spoke on condition of anonymity because he has clients involved with MERS. “So as far as anyone can tell their real theory was: ‘If we can get everyone on board, no judge will want to upend something that is reasonable and sensible and would screw up 70 percent of loans.’ ”
As we’ve also noted, recording clerks in single counties in Massachusetts and North Carolina are looking into how to recover recording fees from MERS, but the cost of litigation means they’d need other counties in the same states to join or the state attorney general to take up the matter. By contrast, the Oregon decisions don’t hit small fry MERS; they are a big problem for the banks themselves. As the Oregonian reports:
Sales of hundreds of foreclosed homes in Oregon have been halted or withdrawn in recent weeks after federal judges repeatedly questioned their legality, according to a number of real estate attorneys in the state.
Lenders have withdrawn more than 300 foreclosure sales since February in Deschutes County alone, one of the Oregon area’s hardest hit by the housing collapse. About 130 of those notices were filed in the past week, attorneys say.
Dozens of foreclosure listings by ReconTrust Co., the foreclosure arm of Bank of America Corp., have disappeared from its website, attorneys say…
Since October, federal judges in five separate Oregon cases have halted foreclosures involving MERS, saying its participation caused lenders to violate the state’s recording law. Three of those decisions came last month, the key one in U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Eugene.
Attorneys say it’s not clear whether lenders in Oregon will simply start over or head to court to foreclose, steps that could prolong the crisis for months and drive up costs, attorneys say. Some suggest lenders might not have access to the documents they need to comply with state law.
“A lot of us are questioning whether there is a solution,” said David Ambrose, a Portland attorney who represents lenders in mortgage transactions. “It’s pretty amazing. There are a lot of unanswered questions.” ….
In Oregon, lenders can foreclose without going to court. But state law also requires that the loan’s ownership history, or assignments, be recorded with local county governments before proceeding with a nonjudicial foreclosure.
In the Eugene court case, Donald E. McCoy III filed for bankruptcy protection in part to block U.S. Bank from foreclosing on his Central Point home. He then sued the bank and MERS, along with his original lender BNC Mortgage Inc., claiming they had not properly recorded BNC’s subsequent sale of the loan to investors.
Chief Bankruptcy Judge Frank R. Alley III found McCoy’s allegation persuasive and refused to grant the bank’s request for a dismissal.
“Oregon law permits foreclosure without the benefit of judicial proceeding only when the interest of the beneficiary (lender) is clearly documented in a public record,” Alley wrote. “When the public record is lacking, the foreclosing beneficiary must prove its interest in a judicial proceeding.”
This looks like an epic fail for the banks, at least in Oregon. To save maybe $50 on recording fees, they are now going to have to go to court to foreclose. And worse for them will be cases where the records don’t pass muster. Recall that servicers advance principal and interest to investors when borrowers become delinquent. They then reimburse themselves out of the foreclosure proceeds. No foreclosure and they are out a lot of dough.
As Morgenson’s source indicated, the banks brazenly assumed that the courts would simply roll over rather than block the extra-legal imposition of a new system. But there is enough of a semblance of rule of law in the US to undermine all the cost savings and corners-cutting they engaged in. Recall this recent New York decision:
This court does not accept the argument that because MERS may be involved with 50 percent of all residential mortgages in the country, that is reason enough for this court to turn a blind eye to the fact that this process does not comply with the law.
The courts are delivering the banks an unrelenting series of deserved unkind cuts. This is getting to be interesting, and for a change, in a good way.
Surface Encounters proudly ensures consumer satisfaction and price putting in granite assurance. “I’m usually skeptical going with new corporations, but your workers has crafted me a believer!” - Steve, Indianapolis
Surface Encounters is a fast-growing
surface encounters organization and, nevertheless they've kept pace with all the recent purchaser referrals. “This organization has become the most cost-effective, trusted and pleasant businesses from the overall state. I would advocate them to everybody.” - Mike R., South Bend
A great deal of deliver the results goes into constructing attractive countertops from nature. The method features laser measurement artistic vein matching, precision diamond and water-jet cutting, edging and qualified installation. 1 can't plainly phone in their purchase to get a customized countertop and also have it within just every day or two. High quality takes time.
Surface Encounters encourages consumers to go to a showroom to know extra about natural stone countertops. Moreover the variety and fabrication practice, one other critical component of buyer treatment is making sure one particular is aware of the right way to treatment for their granite countertop to maintain it searching new for years to arrive.
Granite is known as a wonderful purely natural stone merchandise which can be a well known materials employed for countertops and floor tiles in kitchens and bathrooms. Granite has surpassed marble in recognition since is it even more resilient and much simpler to treatment for. Granite is unmatched by synthetic products for its strength and durability, tolerance to temperature adjustments and resistance to stains and scratches.
Granite is a naturally shaped stone that's quarried from deep inside the earth, harvested, cut, polished, sealed and put in in households to add magnificence, elegance and design. As a result of it is just a purely natural solution, no two slabs are particularly alike. Granite is available in many colors from the numerous minerals that happen to be found while in the rock. Considering that it arrives from throughout the planet, diverse areas and environmental reasons make it distinctive.
Granite is primarily designed up of quartz crystal, but it also features a variety of quantities of other metals which includes feldspar, mica, copper and iron. Some granite may well have bits of gold or silver. The quantity of every metal depends around the area it comes from. All granite is formed right into a tough stone by warmth and pressure. Rain adds other minerals since it is forming. It truly is attainable all over the entire world, in any country, and every single region will produce a
surface encounters extraordinary variety of granite.
Surface Encounters state-of-the-art machinery ensures the greatest good quality completed solution because they style and design and develop some of the greatest kitchens and bathrooms. Granite Countertops boost the warmth and beauty of households even while growing their worth and improving upon lifestyles.
Surface Encounters can be involved with employee morale; thrilled staff are alot more most likely to lead for the victory of a company. Also to becoming a thriving service and 1 that is definitely wonderful to effort for, Surface Encounters does their portion to protect our planet.
Surface Encounters does what is best for his or her potential customers, workers as well as the environment. Surface Encounters makes use of innovative h2o recycling capabilities to recycle approximately 43,000 gallons of drinking water each day. On top of that, one hundred percent of the scrap created in establishing classy kitchens and amazing baths is re-used as aggregate in road developing, surface preparations and concrete.
The Columbus, Ohio Grand Opening of Surface Encounters elements an art gallery showroom of Granite, Marble, Quartz and Engineered Stone counter tops. Retail outlet Manager, Scott Donnelly unlocked the doors of the showroom at 4717 Roberts Road, just west from the I-270 Beltway. The Surface Encounters production course of action employs precision, automated technological innovation throughout the fabrication with the customer's personalized counter leading, this sort of as: a laser measuring alignment that plans the diamond-tipped sculpturing blades. Surface Encounters' plan features computer-driven application that perpetuates the stone's organic veins. Each Surface Encounter retail store has at least a person registered, interior designer to help you in making the finished venture you may be shopping for. The craftsmanship continues with the
House owners are determining to remodel rather than sell their residences in today’s marketplace
Granite countertops have grown to be a prime preference between Wixom shoppers for kitchen remodeling jobs. Kitchen remodeling is usually the first undertaking tackled with families paying 3,000 hours or even more annually in their kitchen. Granite countertops offer an atmosphere that enhances the quality time put in with household and associates. Granite countertops very last a lifetime and enhance the level of quality of residences.
Surface Encounters Wixom store manager, Sal Dellacasa, says there are several reasons individuals are looking for granite for their countertop requires. “Granite countertops add splendor and elegance to a kitchen. Granite is obtainable inside of a selection of vibrant colours and abundant textures and its strength and sturdiness is unmatched by any other purely natural stone or synthetic countertop substance.”
Surface Encounters’ users take pleasure in experienced services and also a friendly, practical staff to information them with the kitchen remodeling system. Countless of Surface Encounters new buyers are referred to them by former clientele.
"This agency is probably the most low-priced, trustworthy, and friendly suppliers from the total state. I would propose them to virtually anyone." Mike R. Clinton Twp., MI
"The company has constantly been there to assist me in whichever way feasible. Thank you a lot!" David V. Lapeer, MI
Surface Encounters Macomb may be the property of half-off granite for kitchen and bathroom countertops. Granite countertops by Surface Encounters have fast turn out to be the top option for Macomb residents who're remodeling their kitchens. Kitchen remodeling normally takes priority with households spending 3,000 hours or more each year in their kitchen. Granite countertops furnish an natural environment that enhances the good quality time invested with friends and family and mates and increase the excellent of properties.
Surface Encounters Macomb shop supervisor, Sal Dellacasa, says there are numerous good reasons shoppers are finding granite for their countertop desires. “Granite countertops add attractiveness and elegance to a kitchen. Granite is offered in a variety of vibrant colors and loaded textures and its strength and sturdiness is unmatched by any other
surface encounters pure stone or artificial countertop material.”
Surface Encounters’ customers delight in certified services as well as a friendly, practical staff to tutorial them with the kitchen remodeling practice. Numerous of Surface Encounters new prospects are referred to them by preceding clients.
